Al’s first model train set

The first train set we got for Al was – of course – a Hornby set. In the UK, “toy” trains and Hornby are synonymous. (Yes, “toys”; since Al was only about 4 year old). Hornby sets are available from all sorts of retailers, in real shops, as well as online, and of course in specialist model shops. We went to a small model shop with an upstairs dedicated to sets. Sadly this shop went out of business a few years ago. They were specialists and stocked other makes of train. Names which at the time I hadn't heard of, such as Bachman. You see this was a “model” shop, not a “toy” shop, and if you haven't found out yet there is a big difference between the two.

Hornby's Eddie Stobart Engine

The set was a great success with Al. He had seen a model train loco at his grandfather's and that got him asking about train sets. We found some of my old set – but this train set was his very own. The set we bought for him was Hornby’s R1061, Eddie Stobart Hauler. I think my review score of it would be “mixed”; it has a great little engine which is still one of the fastest in the family collection; it was an “operating” set – in other words it does more than just go around the tracks; and all of Hornby's train sets are great value compared to buying the individual components. 

  

I think Hornby is in a bit of a fix. It’s managed to build a great revival in its fortunes since the decline of train sets forced the previous owners to give up, and the company which is now Hornby Hobbies was formed. They built that revival, partly on moving manufacture to China, but also on higher degrees of accuracy. They shifted their market focus to adult buyers and away from toy trains. Many of their models are now highly detailed, and they work hard to be true to the original full size versions (what the modelling world calls the “prototype”). And of course adults have more money to spend!

Hornby's Eddie Stobart Goods Container Wagon 

 What I think they have missed is that adult modellers have usually started out as children playing with toy trains. Much of their catalogue is too expensive for kids – in fact even their catalogue itself is pricey on a pocket money budget. They have thankfully introduced the Railroad range in the last couple of years – which is going in the right direction.

  

  

Hornby's Eddie Stobart lowmac wagon

So for me the downsides of the Eddie Stobart set were firstly, the branding itself –Hornby and Stobart chose to use their original c.1950’s branding - but it certainly isn’t the brand image which the kids see on every motorway journey these days. Then there are the wagons – the lowmac and the bogie wagon are both low profile models which feel fairly delicate and are often a fiddle to place correctly onto the tracks. 

  

Finally the operating tipper is a clever piece of engineering, designed to have one edge tip up and unload a pile of – pretty unconvincing – “logs” over the side.  In order to drop over the side, the side rail has to rotate out of the way. But the hinge arrangements are incredibly fine pieces of plastic. With a bit of less than gentle handling, the side comes off, and its then quite a challenge for a child to put it back correctly.

But despite my whingeing, the set has its strong points as well. The inclusion of the Hornby TrakMat I think is a really great invention. It immediately transforms the track into a fantasy setting. It helps you visualise the setting of the railway – the platforms, the engine sheds, and the roadways to service the railway. And the little Eddie Stobart Loco, as I’ve already said, is still one of the fastest in the family collection. So we still look out for the Eddie Stobart lorries on the motorway as we travel around the country, and as we see them, every one is a reminder of the train set waiting for us to get back home again!

Train delayed - Haggis on the track!

We survived the Burns Night, but our test layout didn't. (It was after all on the dinner table, and I didn't think it was quite up to hauling the haggis around the table!). I did manage to catch a few quick camera shots, before it all disappeared. 

Tri-ang R257 on straight section showing catenary

 The first pic shows the train on a straight. You can see how the catenary (overhead wire) sits nicely over the middle of the pantographs. The trouble starts when you drive your train around the bend. 

diagram showing how straight catenary would run on
curved track

Here is a diagram drawn using XtrakCad which shows how a line drawn from centre line at one end of a curve to the centre line at the other end (the black line) actually veers off to the inside of the curve.  The pantographs won’t be able to reach across to this line and so won't collect any power. One alternative would be to split the curve into two – see the red lines. But even this line gets close to the edge line of the pantograph. (This would be the equivalent of the Marklin recommendation for a post every 22.5°).

Tri-ang R257 on curved track showing catenary

The second pic shows the train on a curve. You can see how close the wire is to the edge of the pantograph (where I have added a small yellow arrow). What happens in practice is, unless you get it right, the pantograph slips off the wire. As it is sprung, it extends to its full height, and often continues to pick up power by scrapping along the side of the wire – until CRASH – it hits a post.

As you can see from the video of a couple of posts ago we did manage to get it right. First I had to straighten the individual strands of wire I had bent as a kid. One trick I picked up on the internet was to roll the wire – this shows where the bends actually are. It's quite a painstaking job to bend them back. Our test circuit was built using Tri-ang R483, first radius curves, with three straight sections (R480/R481) on either side of the oval. Without getting every “straight” section of wire really straight, the wire didn't quite meet in the middle. In the end I was able to ease some sections of the wire apart inside the connecting clips. This isn't ideal of course – but it worked!

Tri-ang catenary mast (R419)

One other problem I had was with the mast clips – the little pieces of nylon which hang down from the top of the post. Here is a picture of one of the problem mast clips - if you look carefully you can see the wire is sitting behind the clip. The idea is that you push the wire up into the clip and the nylon springs closed around it, leaving the bottom edge free to touch the pantographs. But several of my old masts - like this one - had clips which just pushed the wire back out and wouldn't grip it. If anyone has any ideas how this might be solved I'd love to hear them.

We now have to work out just how to link in a Tri-ang overhead powered track section can fit into our main layout. We'll let you know if we solve that one!

And in the meantime, the words of Rabbie Burns’ Address to a Haggis are still ringing in my ears – “great Chieftain of the pudding race” – the proof of our pudding was watching the R257 zip around the track using overhead power with head lights blazing!